The Impact of Small vs. Large Cruise Ships

by Oceanwide Expeditions Blog

The generalization that larger ships impact the environment more than smaller ships seems like such a no-brainer that if someone said it to you, you’d be easily forgiven for thinking you were being tricked.

A painfully obvious ship assumption

The generalization that larger ships impact the environment more than smaller ships seems like such a no-brainer that if someone said it to you, you’d be easily forgiven for thinking you were being tricked.

Well, you’re not.

Larger ships do tend to impact the environment more than smaller ships, especially passenger-packed cruise ships – though obviously there are many exceptions, which we’ll address later.

Here a few ways larger cruise ships (thousands of passengers) impact the environment more than smaller ones (100 – 200 passengers), followed by a few ways they don’t.

0 photo

Fewer passengers per cruise ship

The largest of our ships, m/v Hondius, carries 174 passengers. The smallest, s/v Rembrandt van Rijn, carries only 33.

Compare that to traditional cruise ships, the largest of which carry well over 5,000 passengers, not including entertainment staff and crew.

You don’t have to be a mathematician to see that such a large passenger load will by necessity generate far more environmental impact than several smaller ships ever could, assuming they are of equivalent technological sustainability.

1 photo

Cruise ship fuel consumption

You also don’t have to be an engineer to see that hauling thousands of people requires more fuel than carrying fewer than two hundred. Some estimates put the larger cruise ships at up to 250 tons of fuel burned per day (roughly 80,000 gallons).

Meanwhile, our schooner Rembrandt van Rijn can sometimes sail by wind power during parts of its voyages, if the weather cooperates.

2 photo

Assisting with climate science on cruise ships

Lastly, one of the side benefits of polar expedition cruise ships is that they’re often refurbished research vessels. This means they can easily be used again for such purposes in a limited way, such as when scientists need to do small-scale polar work.

We often have researchers on board who are experts in such fields as glaciology, meteorology, and other climate-related sciences. Indeed, our guides often have backgrounds in these fields.

Two of the specific projects we have assisted with recently include the placement of Argo weather profilers and the study of invasive species.

3 photo

We’re also devoted participants of waste removal efforts like Clean Up Svalbard and the Clean Seas campaign. And we are proud, active, longtime members of both AECO and IAATO, with many of our principal colleagues serving in chief positions within these organizations.

So if you’re considering either an Arctic or Antarctica cruise, thinking small can (in most cases) help us keep the polar regions closer to how they were before we ever set foot in them.

Why cruise ships aren’t always better when smaller

This is as much a no-brainer as our main premise, because clearly there are multiple reasons smaller ships are better for the environment.

Indeed, carbon emissions per passenger usually drop with larger cruise ships compared to smaller ones. But much of our impact in the polar regions comes from our landing groups, and in this regard larger cruise ships (thousands of passengers) are not really applicable, since they wouldn’t be able to make landings there anyway.

This is because there is a rule of AECO and IAATO that states there can be no more than 100 guests on shore at any one time, regardless of whether your ship holds 100 or 500 – the current limit that a ship can be classified as an expedition cruise vessel.

So clearly, it’s not so black and white as simply “small vs. large.”

4 photo

Sure, we come out favorably if we compare our ships with those that hold 5,000 people or more. But if you take 5,000 people to Antarctica or the Arctic on one of our ships and compare the impact in CO2 emissions and landings, it’s likely we would have the greater impact.

The issue, then, becomes more about sustainable technology and the reduction of non-degradable waste than ship size, which is why we’re currently in the process of reducing single-use plastics on our ships, among other sustainability efforts.

However you measure it, impact is a complex and systemic issue that requires equally systemic and complex solutions.

5 photo

Image by Richard Wadey

Cruceros relacionados

Exploración al Norte de Spitsbergen - Diversos paisajes, hielo marino y vida salvaje
Hasta US$2600 de descuento

Exploración al Norte de Spitsbergen - Diversos paisajes, hielo marino y vida salvaje

23 jun. - 30 jun., 2025

Código del viaje: HDS04-25

Esta expedición se centra en la versatilidad de los impresionantes paisajes del norte de Spitsbergen, las vastas extensiones de hielo marino y las numerosas oportunidades de avistar ballenas, osos polares, aves marinas, morsas y otros animales salvajes....

Exploración al Norte de Spitsbergen - Diversos paisajes, hielo marino y vida salvaje
Hasta US$3100 de descuento

Exploración al Norte de Spitsbergen - Diversos paisajes, hielo marino y vida salvaje

24 jun. - 1 jul., 2025

Código del viaje: PLA05-25

Últimas literas Svalbard

Esta expedición se centra en la versatilidad de los impresionantes paisajes del norte de Spitsbergen, las vastas extensiones de hielo marino y las numerosas oportunidades de avistar ballenas, osos polares, aves marinas, morsas y otros animales salvajes....

Norte de Spitsbergen 'Basecamp'- Limpieza de las costas, Kayak gratuito, raquetas de nieve / senderismo, taller de fotografía
Hasta US$3100 de descuento

Norte de Spitsbergen 'Basecamp'- Limpieza de las costas, Kayak gratuito, raquetas de nieve / senderismo, taller de fotografía

26 jun. - 3 jul., 2025

Código del viaje: OTL05-25

El crucero Norte Spitsbergen Basecamp le ofrece innumerables formas de explorar y disfrutar de esta región del Ártico. Esta expedición le permite caminar, caminar con raquetas de nieve, kayak y aprender a tomar fotografías perfectas de la flora y fauna...

Alrededor de Spitsbergen - En el reino de Polar Bear & Ice
Hasta US$2200 de descuento

Alrededor de Spitsbergen - En el reino de Polar Bear & Ice

30 jun. - 9 jul., 2025

Código del viaje: HDS05-25

  • EN

Haga un crucero alrededor de Spitsbergen y explore las aguas heladas del Atlántico Norte. Esta especial expedición le ofrecerá la chance de ver ballenas, renos, zorros árticos, morsas, focas, y la atracción estrella, el oso polar.

Alrededor de Spitsbergen - En el reino de Polar Bear & Ice
Hasta US$3800 de descuento

Alrededor de Spitsbergen - En el reino de Polar Bear & Ice

1 jul. - 10 jul., 2025

Código del viaje: PLA06-25

  • EN

Haga un crucero alrededor de Spitsbergen y explore las aguas heladas del Atlántico Norte. Esta especial expedición le ofrecerá la chance de ver ballenas, renos, zorros árticos, morsas, focas, y la atracción estrella, el oso polar.

Loading